How to Check If Your Automated Trading Is Working Correctly

Introduction

Once you activate an automated trading strategy, the question shifts from "how do I execute trades?" to "how do I know it's running as expected?" Monitoring automated trading is different from monitoring manual trades — you're not checking for individual signals, you're verifying that the system is behaving according to its parameters.

---

1. Confirm Trades Are Appearing in Your Broker Account

The most basic check: every trade the platform executes should appear in your broker's order history and position screen. If the platform reports a trade but your broker account shows nothing, there's a connectivity issue that needs immediate attention.

What to check:

• Order history in your Tradier or Tastytrade account
• Open positions match what the platform reports
• Fill prices are close to the expected credit range

---

2. Verify Position Sizing Is Within Parameters

Each iron condor position should represent roughly the capital allocation per position you configured. If positions are significantly larger or smaller than expected, check:

• Number of contracts per position
• Capital being allocated per trade vs. your configured limit
• Whether multiple positions opened simultaneously are within combined exposure limits

---

3. Compare P&L Against Expected Range

After several weeks of operation, your aggregate P&L should be directionally consistent with the strategy's historical parameters. Month-to-month variability is normal — a single losing month doesn't indicate a malfunction. What to watch for:

• Losses significantly larger than the configured stop loss suggests the stop wasn't triggered correctly
• Win rate over 20+ trades diverging dramatically from the historical 85–92% range is worth investigating
• Consistent slippage far above typical bid/ask spreads suggests execution quality issues

---

4. Check Exit Execution

Profit target exits and stop loss exits should execute automatically when thresholds are reached. To verify:

• Review closed trade history and check that exits occurred at or near the configured percentages
• Look for any positions that remained open beyond their stop loss threshold

For context on how exits are managed, see How Automated Options Trading Works in 2026.

---

5. Review the Platform's Trade Log

Tradematic maintains a trade log showing every entry and exit executed across connected accounts. Cross-reference this log with your broker statement monthly to confirm alignment.

If entries or exits don't match, contact platform support before assuming the system is working correctly.

For a broader performance evaluation framework, see How to Verify Trading Strategy Performance.

---

Conclusion

Checking whether automated trading is working correctly means verifying four things: trades appear in the broker account, position sizing matches configuration, P&L aligns with expected ranges, and exits execute at the right thresholds. This review takes 15–20 minutes monthly and should be a standard part of running any automated strategy.

Start your 7-day free trial and access a fully automated iron condor strategy with transparent trade logging from day one.

---

Trading involves risk and losses can occur. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Options trading is not suitable for all investors. Only allocate capital you are comfortable risking.